The Results are in.... Reese's Peanut Butter Cup was the favorite candy amongst Superstar Students and friends with 15 out of 55 votes. York Peppermint Patty came in second with 9 votes, and Almond Joy and Three Musketeers tied for third with 7 votes each. Peanut M & M's and Snickers were the least liked with 1 vote each. I wonder what kind of candy you'll get in your Halloween bucket!!